A bit lumpy

Does give a nice distinct dark and straight line but I find it dries and then starts to crack and or peel off. Almost flaky like. Wouldn't buy again.

I love this eyeliner! For me, it is very easy and precise to apply. It's smudge proof and easily lasts the day. To me this eyeliner is second to none.

Love using this. Brush is tricky but product is great.

Okay so this product is easy to apply and it looks good. The problem for me comes with trying to get it off again. Using makeup remover and a cotton pad/bud doesn't cut it (and I've used several different types of remover). I end up having to kind of peel it off in little bits. Maybe this is just my problem but I found this so frustrating and ended up throwing mine out after many struggles. Sigh! But if you don't care about spending hours trying to get it out of your eyes, it is a good liquid eyeliner.

This is my go to liquid eyeliner. It lasts all day and doesn't smudge! It's super easy to remove and it doesn't irritate my eyes. The one thing that lets it down is the applicator. I just find it difficult to apply without accidentally getting some product on my lashes. But the eyeliner is the best I've used so far.

Great staying power but a little too hard to use compared the effortless finish of other eyeliners. Making the switch to natural cosmetics is a learning curve. It just didn't go on flawlessly and it is difficult to get a perfect wing. Very glossy as well, so probably only suitable for night as it is not subtle.

My go to liner. I used to use a higher end brand that didnt rub off but it irritated my eyes (I wear contacts). This does not irritate my eyes at all!!!

This has the best finish of any eye liner i have used. It's clear and precise. It's more difficult to apply than a pencil but the result is worth the extra effort. Stays on all day and never smudges! My only issue with the product is that it is very difficult to get a thicker line.

better than my normal , doesn't smudge

I really love this eyeliner, although I don't tend to wear it often. It really takes a while to get used to application as the brush tip is long and flexible, and the liquid is quite runny until it sets. It doesn't irritate my eyes which is a big plus and tends to stay quite nicely although when it does start to come off, it does so in chunks so requires a bit of touching up. I will occasionally have some rub off onto my upper eyelid and have learnt not to wear a shimmer eyeshadow with it as it sticks to the liner over time. I feel that both of these issues are due to the shape of my eyes though. Another thing to keep in mind is that it has a shiny finish, not matte.

I have tried tried so many eyeliners high end to low,this the best for sensitive skin..would re purchase it.

I love this eyeliner! Easy to use, smooth and consistent, and it STAYS put. Great value for the price too.

But since its a review I have to recommend the heck out of this. It stays and its easy to put on. Get it!

I am slowly making the change to be chemical free, I was feeling a bit skeptical about make-up, especially since I love a nice winged eye! This still smells good, goes on smoothly and doesn't smudge or move all day! I need 12 hour coverage and this delivers. I also have VERY sensitive skin and this stuff feels amazing all day, no itchiness at all.

Goes on smoothly, is precise and stays on. Love it!

Didn't like this one. I have oily skin so it still came off.

I will not use another liquid eye liner after using this one. I just find it easy to use and lots so long - doesn't smudge. Love it

I am crazy about this eyeliner! First one I have found that will last the humid summers in QLD and not run or smudge. The brush is super thin and makes it easy to apply.

Great black colour. It lasts until I am ready to take it off (and I have an oily skin), and sometimes it is a bit tricky to remove, especially if I have accidentally got it to my eyelashes but a good oil does the trick for me.

Very black, easy to apply, it lasts. Some reviews talk about it being tricky to take off. I found a little coconut oil and a cloth wipe and it came off really easily.

This is the HOLY GRAIL of liquid eyeliners. Stays on ALL day and is AMAZING. The only issue is...me. I am abit unco-ordinated and it smudges. Its getting better with a few weeks of practice...

I love this eyeliner!!

The pigment is dark black, the brush is easy to use, and the best thing is this won't budge all day! Love it!

Goes on ok but drys abit flaky

Great black pigment, easy to apply, stays on firm all day! Its a bit tricky to get off with a microfiber make up remover pad, but a little coconut oil helps it cone off easily. I'll definitely buy this again!

I've always struggled to apply eyeliner. This one is super easy to apply and stays on all day and night if needed. Totally smudge proof once dry and easy to correct whilst wet. And black as black. Love it so much I wear it almost every day.

I love it. The black is bold and BLACK and is hard to come off (which is good during the day, a bit annoying at the end of the day). I'd give it 100 stars if I could because taking a look at the ingredients it is all natural.

Welcome to the best eyeliner. It literally lasts all day and I find it so difficult to take it off at the end of the day. For a liquid liner it's easy to apply and easy to build a bold black line/wing.

I really love using this eyeliner. I was looking for a thin brush like this in an ethical line for a long time. Only problem is I am having trouble getting it off. I tried coconut oil but only helped a little. I'm losing eyelashes! Any ideas?

long lasting, highly pigmented and easy to apply! perfect wings

Its long lasting and doesn't make my eyes become smudgy.

For a long time I struggled to find a liquid eyeliner that would not smudge. I previously found one that did, but it was loaded with chemicals and that always made me uneasy.
I was skeptical purchasing this at first particularly due to the price, but I'm so glad I did, it is honestly worth every cent.