The product is a great disappointment. I like beach spray by Noosa Basics, so I decided to give their face wash a try. The product is absolutely ineffective. I would give it a zero if I could. I think it would be too gross to attach the photos of messy make up rounds here stained and smeared all over - and that's after using the foaming face wash. I mean , after using it, I still need to use something else or apply a very generous amount of micellar water to the face. The foaming face wash doesn't remove any make up at all and/or skin oil, impurities or anything else which would accumulate on your face during day time. And I mainly use natural make up - nothing too heavy or excessive. But the face wash can't remove even that. The smell is offputting - too 'natural' and cheap like a grannie's perfume which has been sitting on the dressing table since 1920s. . A total failure, in my opinion. A face wash should still be a face wash. I used other clean brands before and they were not as horrible as that one. I would actually want to get a refund for that if I could.