This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Up To 40% Off Store Wide

FREE Shipping On Orders $49+

FREE Sample Box with orders $149+

Your Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $49 away from free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Products
Pair with

FREE Sample Box when you spend $149

Add order notes
Subtotal Free
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Natural Eye Makeup

The eyes have it, and so do we, naturally! Create your perfect eye makeup look, with these natural & organic mascara's, eyeshadows, eyeliners and brow enhancers. Always free from toxins and kind to the delicate eye area.

Filters

Product Filter
Shopping Preferences
Active ingredient
Brand
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
An open tube of Benecos Mascara Super Long Lashes 8ml with a black tube, silver cap, and exposed wand with feather design packaging for naturally long lashes.
 
A black tube of Benecos Multi Effect Mascara 8ml with the wand upright beside the open tube. This vegan mascara, suitable for sensitive eyes, features purple decorative text and design on the packaging.
 
A black tube of Benecos Mascara Vegan Volume 8ml with the cap off reveals the wand coated in volumizing mascara, set against a plain white background.
 
A tube of Benecos Mascara Adorable Lashes 5.5ml with a blue cap and a curved brush wand stands upright by the open tube, labeled for creating flexible, lengthened lashes.
 
A rose gold tube of INIKA Organic Purity Lash Mascara with the cap off and wand upright beside it—ideal for sensitive eyes—set against a white background.
 
A gray tube of Madara Bold Volume Mascara - Deep Matter stands upright with its black wand beside it, highlighting its natural, vegan formula for buildable bold lash volume.
 
INIKA Organic Liquid Eyeliner 15.9g is a vegan, smudge-proof matte black liquid liner with a long cap and fine brush applicator, shown open next to the bottle featuring INIKA ORGANIC in gold lettering.
 
A black tube of Benecos Liquid Eyeliner 3ml stands upright with its cap off, showing a thin, pointed brush applicator.
 

Popular Q&A's for Natural Eye Makeup

1. What are the benefits of using natural eye makeup?

Natural eye makeup enhances your eyes with gentle, non-irritating formulas that care for the delicate skin around your eyes. These products are often made with natural pigments, minerals, and botanical extracts that nourish and protect your skin while providing beautiful, long-lasting colour.

2. How do I create a natural everyday eye makeup look?

For a natural everyday look, start with a light eyeshadow shade all over your eyelid. Then, apply a slightly darker shade to the crease of your eyelid for definition. Finish with mascara to lengthen and define your lashes. You can also add a touch of eyeliner to the outer corners of your eyes for a subtle lift.

3. How do I create a smoky eye look with natural makeup?

Start by applying a medium-toned eyeshadow all over your eyelid. Then, apply a darker shade to the crease and outer corners of your eyes, blending well. Use a black or dark brown eyeliner to line your upper and lower lash lines, smudging it slightly for a smoky effect. Finish with mascara for dramatic lashes.

4. How do I choose the right natural eye makeup for my skin tone?

Consider your skin tone and undertone when choosing natural eye makeup. If you have fair skin, opt for lighter shades of eyeshadow and eyeliner. For medium skin tones, a wider range of colours will work well. If you have dark skin, you can experiment with bolder, more vibrant shades.

5. How do I remove natural eye makeup without irritating my eyes?

Natural eye makeup is typically easy to remove with a gentle cleanser or makeup remover. Look for oil-based cleansers or those specifically designed for eye makeup removal. Apply the cleanser or remover to a cotton pad and gently wipe away your eye makeup. Avoid rubbing or pulling on the delicate skin around your eyes.

Earn Juicy Rewards

Login to earn Juicy Rewards on every order.